| Prudence, Passion and Persuasion in Moby Dick | | | |
-
<< Back to editing
-
Previous version by
-
-
<< Older
-
Newer >>
-
Revert to this one
search results
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
/index.php?action=ajax&rs=GDMgetPage&rsargs[]=laissezfaire26_3.pdf&rsargs[]=0
__________________________________________________________________
Cecil
E
.
Bohanon
Prudence
,
Passion
and
Persuasion
in
Moby
Dick
McCloskey
(
1998
)
has
argued
that
prudence
is
a
central
and
necessary
virtue
in
a
capitalist
economy
.
However
she
points
out
that
prudence
does
not
and
cannot
explain
all
economic
behavior
.
Prudence
is
in
contrast
with
another
virtue
:
solidarity
with
fellow
humans
.
Solidarity
is
negotiated
by
rhetoric
and
discourse
,
and
is
central
to
the
operation
of
all
human
societies
including
and
perhaps
especially
ones
that
are
capitalistic
.
Prudence
is
at
odds
with
solidarity
,
while
simultaneously
requiring
solidarity
for
its
own
operation
.
The
prisoners
’
dilemma
,
for
example
,
is
not
overcome
by
simple
prudential
self-regarding
calculation
(
indeed
,
that
is
why
it
is
a
problem
!)
but
by
solidarity
with
embedded
social
practices
and
customs
.
But
it
is
this
solidarity
that
allows
for
greater
degrees
of
prudential
activity
.
In
the
same
vein
,
solidarity
hardly
stands
alone
.
Although
“
dull
”
prudence
can
scarcely
be
seen
as
a
universal
motivation
for
human
action
,
prudence
is
a
useful
and
necessary
means
for
attaining
noble
and
heroic
ends
.
Yet
prudence
is
often
in
conflict
with
reckless
courage
,
unrequited
generosity
,
unwavering
commitment
and
a
variety
of
other
more
passionate
virtues
.
Cecil
E
.
Bohanon
is
Professor
of
Economics
,
Ball
State
University
(
Muncie
,
Indiana
).
A
preliminary
version
of
this
paper
was
presented
at
the
annual
meeting
of
the
Association
of
Private
Enterprise
Education
(
APEE
)
in
Cancún
,
Mexico
,
April
8
–
10
,
2007
.
(
The
author
would
like
to
thank
Lee
Craig
for
helpful
comments
.
Any
errors
remain
the
author
’
s
.)
This
paper
argues
that
Herman
Melville
’
s
1851
classic
Moby
Dick
can
be
seen
as
a
referendum
between
prudence
and
passion
:
between
mercantile
gains
and
heroic
questing
,
and
the
tragic
triumph
of
the
latter
over
the
former
.
The
irony
is
that
passion
defeats
prudence
on
prudence
’
s
own
terms
.
Captain
Ahab
takes
the
role
of
passion
,
first-mate
Starbuck
is
the
spokesperson
for
prudence
.
The
ship
’
s
crew
is
the
body
that
judges
the
two
competing
claims
,
revealing
their
preferences
through
their
actions
.
The
key
question
of
the
story
is
why
do
the
members
of
the
crew
go
along
with
Ahab
’
s
self-destructive
quest
?
Whaling
was
a
profit-seeking
business
.
1
Ship
owners
structured
incentives
to
ensure
that
their
interests
coincided
with
those
of
the
crew
.
The
crew
had
a
share
in
the
ship
’
s
cargo
(
whale
oil
)
and
,
as
most
of
the
ship
’
s
costs
were
fixed
costs
,
additional
whales
were
pure
profit
for
all
those
involved
.
Yet
the
whole
story
of
Moby
Dick
is
one
of
intentionally
abandoning
profit-seeking
to
indulge
Captain
Ahab
’
s
grudge
against
the
great
white
whale
.
It
is
important
to
note
that
this
is
accomplished
because
Ahab
is
able
to
persuade
the
crew
to
follow
his
quest
,
his
passionate
cause
of
ridding
the
ocean
of
1
See
Ellickson
(
1989
),
Craig
and
Knobner
(
1992
),
and
Craig
and
Fearn
(
1993
)
for
detailed
outlining
of
the
rules
,
customs
,
practices
and
arrangements
that
are
consistent
with
profit
maximization
in
the
whaling
industry
in
Melville
’
s
time
.
__________________________________________________________________
Laissez-Faire
23
/index.php?action=ajax&rs=GDMgetPage&rsargs[]=laissezfaire26_3.pdf&rsargs[]=1
__________________________________________________________________
the
monster
Moby
Dick
to
the
exclusion
of
profit
and
ultimately
at
the
cost
of
the
crew
’
s
lives
.
The
plan
of
this
paper
is
a
bit
unconventional
.
I
will
follow
the
basic
outline
of
Melville
’
s
story
illustrating
my
thesis
using
direct
quotes
from
Melville
’
s
text
.
I
will
also
offer
a
number
of
other
insights
.
All
the
quoted
material
is
referenced
by
chapter
.
Longer
passages
are
in
italics
.
The
Whaling
Ship
:
Ishmael
and
Queequeg
sign
on
for
the
Pequod
The
protagonist
in
Melville
’
s
Moby
Dick
is
a
late
twenty-something
adventurerwriter
named
Ishmael
,
who
makes
an
accidental
acquaintance
and
ultimately
a
close
friendship
with
the
South
Sea
Islander
Queequeg
in
New
Bedford
,
Massachusetts
.
The
two
agree
to
sign
onto
a
whaling
ship
.
In
Chapter
16
,
Ishmael
describes
signing
on
to
the
whaling
ship
Pequod
.
The
chapter
reveals
a
number
of
details
about
the
financing
of
whaling
operations
.
A
whaling
voyage
typically
lasted
for
up
to
three
years
.
The
supplies
necessary
to
support
the
crew
were
provided
by
the
ship
’
s
owners
,
who
in
this
story
are
two
retired
Quaker
whalers
named
Captain
Bildad
and
Captain
Peleg
.
These
two
are
the
“
largest
owners
of
the
vessel
,”
although
other
shares
were
held
by
“
a
crowd
of
old
annuitants
,
widows
,
fatherless
children
,
and
charity
wards
.”
Ishmael
reveals
the
structure
of
incentives
for
the
crew
:
“
I
was
already
aware
that
in
the
whaling
business
they
paid
no
wages
,
but
all
hands
,
including
the
captain
received
certain
shares
of
the
profits
called
lays
.”
Ishmael
goes
on
to
explain
that
the
lays
reflected
an
ex-ante
estimate
of
the
sailors
marginal
product
:
“
…
these
lays
were
proportionate
to
the
degree
of
importance
pertaining
to
the
respective
duties
of
the
ship
’
s
company
.”
Expecting
a
1
/
275
th
lay
,
and
hoping
for
a
1
/
200
th
,
Ishmael
is
offered
a
1
/
777
th
lay
by
the
more
penurious
owner
,
Bildad
.
Peleg
objects
(“
thou
dost
not
want
to
swindle
this
young
Man
”),
and
eventually
the
three
,
Bildad
,
Peleg
and
Ishmael
,
agree
on
a
1
/
300
th
lay
.
2
Ishmael
’
s
companion
Queequeg
was
an
experienced
whale
harpooner
.
His
lay
negotiation
,
described
in
Chapter
20
,
is
a
classic
illustration
of
how
the
desire
for
prudential
gain
trumps
passion-based
provincial
prejudices
.
When
Queequeg
,
a
South
Sea
Islanders
,
attempts
to
sign
on
for
the
Pequod
Captain
Peleg
asserts
:
“
no
cannibals
on
board
(
unless
)
...
(
thou
)
art
at
present
in
communion
with
a
Christian
church
.”
Ishmael
insists
that
Queequeg
is
a
member
of
the
“
First
Congregation
of
the
whole
Worshiping
World
....”
This
flippant
reply
assuages
Peleg
,
who
goes
on
to
question
Queequeg
:
“
Did
you
ever
strike
a
fish
?”
The
text
then
describes
:
Without
saying
a
word
,
Queequeg
,
in
his
wild
sort
of
way
,
jumped
upon
the
bulwarks
,
from
thence
into
the
bows
of
one
of
the
whale
boats
hanging
on
the
side
;
and
then
bracing
his
left
knee
,
and
posing
his
harpoon
,
cried
out
in
some
such
way
as
this
‘
Cap
’
ain
,
you
see
him
small
drop
tar
on
water
dere
?
You
see
him
?
Well
,
spose
him
one
whale
eye
,
well
,
den
!’
and
taking
sharp
aim
at
it
,
he
darted
the
iron
right
over
old
Bildad
’
s
broad-brim
,
clean
across
the
ship
’
s
deck
and
struck
the
glistening
tar-spot
out
of
sight
.
‘
Now
’
said
2
Perhaps
Bildad
and
Peleg
were
engaging
in
a
“
good
cop
,
bad
cop
”
strategy
.
Bildad
gave
an
absurdly
low
lay
,
allowing
Peleg
’
s
lay
to
seem
generous
,
although
less
than
what
Ishmael
anticipated
.
__________________________________________________________________
Laissez-Faire
24
/index.php?action=ajax&rs=GDMgetPage&rsargs[]=laissezfaire26_3.pdf&rsargs[]=2
__________________________________________________________________
Queequeg
,
quietly
hauling
in
the
line
,
‘
spos-ee
him
whale-e
eye
,
why
,
dad
whale
dead
.’
‘
Quick
,
Bildad
’
said
Peleg
‘
…
get
the
ship
’
s
papers
.
We
must
have
Hedgehog
there
…
we
’
ll
give
ye
the
ninetieth
lay
,
and
that
’
s
more
than
ever
was
given
a
harpooner
yet
out
of
Nantucket
.
During
Ishmael
’
s
negotiations
in
Chapter
16
he
inquired
as
to
the
ship
’
s
captain
.
The
owner
Peleg
reveals
that
Ahab
is
“
a
queer
man
,”
but
that
I
know
Ahab
well
;
I
’
ve
sailed
with
him
as
mate
years
ago
;
and
know
what
he
is
—
a
good
man
—
…
I
know
too
that
ever
since
he
lost
his
leg
last
voyage
by
that
accursed
whale
,
he
’
s
been
a
kind
of
moody
…
it
is
better
to
sail
with
a
moody
good
captain
than
a
laughing
bad
one
.
Although
aware
of
Ahab
’
s
misfortune
,
the
ship
owners
have
no
indication
that
Ahab
will
behave
in
an
inappropriate
way
.
Chapter
26
introduces
the
first-mate
Starbuck
,
whose
motives
are
made
clear
:
Starbuck
was
no
crusader
after
perils
;
in
him
courage
was
not
a
sentiment
;
but
a
thing
simply
useful
to
him
…
courage
was
one
of
the
great
staple
outfits
of
the
ship
,
like
her
beef
and
her
bread
,
and
not
foolishly
to
be
wasted
.
Starbuck
evinced
that
“
I
will
have
no
man
in
my
boat
who
is
not
afraid
of
whales
,”
and
reveals
:
“
I
am
here
in
this
critical
ocean
to
kill
whales
for
my
living
,
and
not
to
be
killed
by
them
for
theirs
…
”
Starbuck
is
the
voice
of
prudence
.
He
is
in
the
voyage
for
gain
,
not
for
romance
,
adventure
or
pleasure
.
Ahab
Reveals
his
Mission
Ishmael
and
Queequeg
set
sail
with
the
rest
of
the
crew
.
For
several
days
Captain
Ahab
remains
reclusive
.
In
Chapter
36
Ahab
reveals
to
the
crew
his
quest
for
Moby
Dick
.
He
begins
by
addressing
the
crew
,
asking
a
number
of
“
seemingly
purposeless
questions
”
to
the
crew
about
whaling
:
“
What
do
you
do
when
ye
see
a
whale
,
men
”
Ahab
asks
;
to
whit
the
crew
replies
“
sing
out
for
him
!”
...
And
once
on
the
rowboat
in
pursuit
of
the
whale
“...
what
tune
is
it
that
ye
pull
to
men
?”
–
“
A
dead
whale
or
a
stove
boat
!”
(
Note
that
stove
in
this
context
means
broken
,
or
a
boat
that
is
crushed
inward
.)
The
crew
“
marveled
”
at
“
how
excited
”
they
became
at
this
line
of
questioning
by
Ahab
.
Ahab
then
holds
up
a
Spanish
ounce
of
gold
,
a
$
16
gold
piece
,
and
nails
it
on
the
mainmast
,
saying
“
Whosoever
of
ye
raises
me
a
white
head
whale
...
shall
have
this
gold
ounce
.”
The
crew
cheers
.
The
three
“
pagan
”
harpooners
(
Tashtego
,
Daggoo
and
Queequeg
)
ask
if
it
is
the
white
whale
known
as
Moby
Dick
.
The
first
mate
Starbuck
asks
if
this
is
the
whale
that
removed
Ahab
’
s
leg
.
Ahab
enthusiastically
replies
in
the
affirmative
to
both
queries
and
then
announces
:
“
Aye
,
aye
and
I
’
ll
chase
him
around
Good
Hope
,
and
round
the
Horn
,
and
round
the
Norway
Maelstrom
,
and
round
perdition
’
s
flames
before
I
give
him
up
.”
He
then
goes
on
to
say
:
“
And
this
is
what
ye
have
shipped
for
,
Men
!
[
emphasis
added
]
To
chase
that
white
whale
on
both
sides
of
land
,
and
over
all
sides
of
earth
,
till
he
spouts
black
blood
and
rolls
fin
out
.
What
say
ye
,
men
,
will
ye
splice
hands
on
it
now
?
I
think
ye
do
look
brave
.”
3
3
“
Splice
hands
”
means
agree
to
it
.
__________________________________________________________________
Laissez-Faire
25
/index.php?action=ajax&rs=GDMgetPage&rsargs[]=laissezfaire26_3.pdf&rsargs[]=3
__________________________________________________________________
Note
that
Ahab
putatively
leaves
it
open
to
the
men
to
agree
or
not
to
the
unconventional
mission
statement
for
the
journey
.
The
crew
replies
:
“
Aye
!
aye
!”
shouted
the
harpooners
and
seamen
,
running
closer
to
the
excited
old
man
:
“
A
sharp
eye
for
the
white
whale
,
a
sharp
lance
for
Moby
Dick
!”
To
which
Ahab
replies
in
a
“
half
sob
and
half
shout
”:
“
God
bless
ye
,
God
bless
ye
men
,”
and
proceeds
to
order
up
grog
for
the
whole
crew
.
Ahab
immediately
notes
that
Starbuck
seems
unenthusiastic
:
“
But
why
the
long
face
about
,
Mr
.
Starbuck
?
Wilt
thou
not
chase
the
white
whale
?
Art
thou
not
game
for
Moby
Dick
?”
Starbuck
replies
in
front
of
the
entire
crew
:
“
I
am
game
for
his
crooked
jaws
and
the
jaws
of
Death
too
,
Captain
Ahab
,
if
it
fairly
comes
in
the
way
of
the
business
we
follow
,
but
I
came
here
to
hunt
whales
,
not
my
commander
’
s
vengeance
.
How
many
barrels
will
thy
vengeance
yield
thee
even
if
thou
gettest
it
,
Captain
Ahab
?
It
will
not
fetch
thee
much
in
our
Nantucket
market
.”
The
debate
has
now
begun
:
Ahab
and
Starbuck
engage
in
a
continual
dialogue
about
the
propriety
of
the
mission
.
Some
of
these
debates
are
in
front
of
the
crew
and
some
are
private
.
Ahab
continues
at
this
juncture
to
reply
,
in
front
of
the
crew
,
giving
the
quest
a
larger
and
more
metaphysical
purpose
,
although
couched
in
commercial
language
,
by
ascribing
to
Moby
Dick
“
an
inscrutable
malice
”:
“
That
inscrutable
thing
is
chiefly
what
I
hate
;
and
be
the
white
whale
agent
,
or
be
the
white
whale
principal
,
I
will
wreak
that
hate
upon
him
.”
He
asserts
to
Starbuck
that
the
crew
is
in
harmony
with
his
purpose
:
“
Look
!
See
yonder
Turkish
cheeks
of
spotted
tawn
…
the
pagan
leopards
…
that
live
;
and
seek
,
and
give
no
reasons
for
the
torrid
life
they
feel
!
The
crew
,
man
,
the
crew
!
Are
they
not
one
and
all
with
Ahab
,
in
this
matter
of
the
whale
?”
Under
his
breath
Ahab
ends
up
concluding
that
“
Starbuck
now
is
mine
;
cannot
oppose
me
now
,
without
rebellion
.”
Ahab
continues
to
ritually
drink
grog
and
cross
lances
and
swords
with
the
men
of
the
crew
to
seal
the
pact
:
“
Drink
ye
harpooners
!
Drink
and
swear
,
ye
men
that
man
the
deathful
whaleboat
’
s
bow
—
Death
to
Moby
Dick
!
God
hunt
us
all
,
if
we
do
not
hunt
Moby
Dick
to
his
death
!”
Later
that
evening
(
in
Chapter
38
)
Starbuck
reflects
:
“
My
soul
is
more
than
matched
;
she
’
s
overmanned
;
and
by
a
madman
…
he
drilled
deep
down
,
and
blasted
all
my
reason
out
of
me
!
I
think
I
see
his
impious
end
;
but
feel
I
must
help
him
to
it
.”
Not
only
has
Ahab
been
able
to
persuade
the
crew
to
his
purpose
,
Prudence
itself
(
in
the
person
of
Starbuck
)
is
swayed
by
his
passion
.
Yet
Chapter
46
reveals
that
Passion
uses
the
tools
of
Prudence
to
attain
its
ends
.
Ahab
’
s
Prudential
Strategy
Chapter
46
of
Moby
Dick
is
titled
Surmises
,
and
reveal
Ahab
’
s
thinking
after
his
initial
interaction
with
the
crew
and
Starbuck
.
“
Starbuck
’
s
coerced
will
were
Ahab
’
s
,
so
long
as
Ahab
kept
his
magnet
at
Starbuck
’
s
brain
;
still
he
knew
for
all
this
the
chief
mate
,
in
his
soul
,
abhorred
his
captain
’
s
quest
,
and
could
he
,
would
joyfully
disintegrate
himself
from
it
,
or
even
frustrate
it
.”
He
goes
on
to
note
that
:
“
Starbuck
would
ever
be
apt
to
fall
into
__________________________________________________________________
Laissez-Faire
26
|
|